Catapulting into Classical

A headlong leap into music, history, and composing

Difficult Times for Classical Music

5 Comments

Image of music staves with complex time signatures with caption "These are difficult times."

Recently, I was talking with some folks who were lamenting the dwindling size of classical concert audiences, and we were trying to think of ways to rebuild them.  It’s a nearly universal phenomenon.

I think I understand one of the reasons why classical music (concert or recording) is such a hard sell these days.

Time.

Or rather, time and focus.

Both, it would seem, are in precious little supply these days.  There is more to do, there are shorter deadlines, there are more things vying for our attention.

And a symphony takes, say, 45 minutes.  Nobody has 45 minutes in one block anymore.  And that’s just listening time.  If you’re going to a concert, you have to include travel time, intermission…you get the idea.  And to get to the concert, you’re probably going to have to fight traffic, not conducive to preparing one for focused listening.  Oh, and don’t forget to turn off your phone before the concert (and check if there’s anything you need to attend to immediately?).  After the concert, when you turn your phone back on, it will be sure to alert you if you missed anything.

But then, people go to pop concerts.  Since the time commitment’s the same, what’s different?  Well, there’s more moving around on stage, possibly dancing.  People have their phones out taking pictures or videos, tweeting.  There might be a light show* and pyrotechnics.  I don’t advocate pyrotechnics for a classical concert (except in the case of the 1812 Overture, then definitely).  And it’s hard to dance with a cello.

And, the obvious, the songs are shorter, the form of the music is easier to grasp, and the tempi are probably faster.  James Gleick, in his book Faster,1 explored the speeding up of modern life; others have noted the same trends.  You can have your groceries delivered if you have no time to shop, and make dinner in an Instant Pot cooker if you have no time to cook.  Texts have replaced emails, which replaced written letters (cursive writing is facing near extinction).  We are in the age of the tweet and tl;dr (too long; didn’t read…thank you for your continued reading!)

What was the complaint about Glenn Gould’s Goldberg Variations in 1981?  Oh yeah—too slow.  Was he trying to tell us something?

 

Schubert’s sonatas have been said to unfold “at heavenly length.”**

When was the last time you had the luxury of that kind of time?

 

So, what do we do about these concerts?  I wish I had a surefire answer.  We might make them more approachable, more lively.  We might change the programming a little; in the early 20th century, one might hear a sonata movement, not the entire sonata.  That’s not necessarily true to the composer’s intent, but now, if something catches your ear, you can probably hear the rest of it on demand and explore.  Others have noted the tyranny that audio recording has imposed on live performance—there is less risk-taking, because people want to hear what they heard in the recording, which is flawless, immaculate (and the product of numerous takes and editing).  I’d prefer to hear someone playing from their soul, taking some risks, even if it means a few mistakes are made.

Or we can hope that the pendulum will swing back, and people will begin to turn away from the relentless jangling go go go of getting and spending,2 quick, easy, fast, now living, and turn more toward a slower, more deliberate pace, with focused attention and the taking of time.  And, with that, the savoring of classical music.

Thank you for your precious time and attention, now and always.

And now, Glenn Gould’s 1981 version of the Aria from Bach’s Goldberg Variations.

 

Footnotes

*The organist Virgil Fox had light shows at some of his concerts.  But then that was the 1970s…

**Robert Schumann first applied it to Schubert’s Symphony in C Major; it was later more broadly applied to his sonatas.

References

  1. Gleick, James,  Faster.  New York: Pantheon Books, 1999.
  2. from William Wordsworth’s The World Is Too Much With Us, via poetryfoundation.org. It was written around 1802, published in 1807 (also see Written in London. September, 1802).

____

Image attribution: Difficult times via https://imgur.com/gallery/Mb8q5.

5 thoughts on “Difficult Times for Classical Music

  1. Interesting article. I went to a professional orchestra concert last November, and expected to hear “classical” music. Instead, the music was more modern. In many pieces the orchestra played background to two singers, and to a gospel-type choir. The audience loved it. I suppose that to survive, orchestras have to please their audiences.
    I belong to a small-town community orchestra, and our next concert will feature movie and musical hits, not anything classical. I know our audience will like that too, better that if we played purely classical music.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I’ve heard of a number of orchestras taking similar approaches. It would be nice if it would be possible to mix the program harmoniously, combining what folks traditionally call classical with more modern music (and it seems a lot of classical music has been used in the movies, which could make a good program). And if you could get a choir that could do gospel and Handel–that would be a home run in my book! But most importantly, the fact that there are still “small-town community orchestras” and people who come out to hear them warms my heart. Thanks!

      Like

  2. The time I spend on some mornings in a trafic jams are fully sufficient for one of Tchaikovsky’s Piano Concertos or a Bruckner symphony. This said, the issue does not seem to be time but priorities. The audience of Beethoven and the like did often not have to work or run a household. They had plenty of time to socialize and concert venues were one out of many occasions to socialize. Now, if today we take together the time we spend on social networks or watching reality shows – that should be enough for Schubert’s never-ending pieces. It’s not about time, it about our priorities.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Sad, but this is the way people think. But then, if you don’ have time for a Beethoven Symphony or a Bach Cantata, why do you have time for the latest regurgitated Star Wars/Trek/Batman movie, or the time to binge on Game of Thrones?

    What people really mean when they say that is that it’s easier to be passive consumers, reacting to stimuli, rather than being engaged in what it is that makes us human. People “don’t have time” for Shakespeare or Chekov anymore either. More fun to check out on social media. There is a wonderful and prophetic movie called Idiocracy which nicely portrays the not too distant future.

    On this business of orchestras not playing classical music but moving to jazz and show tunes, that is a sad economic necessity. Makes me feel sorry for the musicians.

    On a lighter note, in terms of reinvigorating classical music, have you seen the Amazon TV show “Mozart in the Jungle?” It’s basically a soap opera about a symphony orchestra in New York. It has an amazingly good cast and portrays classical musicians as normal and cool and includes a lot of good music and just a bit of education on music.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I used to enjoy Idiocracy, but lately it makes me more and more uncomfortable as it inches toward nonfiction. I have seen some of Mozart in the Jungle, and I hope that it’s getting more people interested in the music.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.